Wondering whether profit alone tells you how well a business is doing? The triple bottom line says no: it measures people, planet and profit side by side. Here is how it works and where it falls short.
This page sits within the wider topic of sustainability in business, where the triple bottom line is one of several ways to measure performance.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Phrase “triple bottom line” first coined | 1994, by John Elkington |
| Earlier framework with the same three parts | 1981, by Freer Spreckley |
| Shell’s first sustainability report | 1997 |
| Largest 250 corporations using GRI reporting | 75% (2017 data) |
| National top 100 firms using GRI reporting | 63% (2017 data) |
| US assets under ESG investment strategies | $11.6 trillion at the start of 2018 |
The figures come from the HEC Paris executive factsheet and Wikipedia’s triple bottom line entry. They can change, so check the source before you rely on them.
What the triple bottom line measures
In ordinary accounting, the bottom line is the net profit a company makes after all its costs have been accounted for, as the Robeco glossary puts it. The triple bottom line argues that this single number is too narrow. Performance should be assessed along three dimensions: social, environmental and economic, according to the HEC Paris factsheet.
- People is the social bottom line: a firm’s contribution to social equity and welfare.
- Planet is the environmental bottom line: a firm’s ecological impact.
- Profit is the economic bottom line, the one every business already tracks.
The framework also shifts who a company answers to. Wikipedia describes it as demanding that a company’s responsibility lies with stakeholders rather than shareholders. Its examples of stakeholders are:
- employees and customers
- suppliers and local residents
- government agencies and creditors
A mining company shows why this matters. According to Robeco, it could make a handsome profit from extracting minerals while its operations harm the environment or people in the event of an accident or pollution spill.
Where the idea came from
The roots go back further than the catchy name. Wikipedia credits Freer Spreckley with first articulating the framework in 1981, in a publication called Social Audit – A Management Tool for Co-operative Working. John Elkington then coined the phrase in 1994, according to the HEC factsheet, and developed it more fully in his 1997 book Cannibals with Forks.
Elkington’s motive was to widen a debate that had narrowed to resource efficiency. In a Mother Jones interview, he said that focusing on eco-efficiency meant you were certainly missing out on the social agenda. He also called the phrase “very consciously business language”, a sort of Trojan horse meant to get companies using it.
His hopes were large. The HEC factsheet says he expected firms to add two further bottom lines to the original one, and hoped companies would then compete on their actual value to society rather than only on financial performance.
The phrase “people, planet, profit” gained a high-profile user early. It was later used as the title of the Anglo-Dutch oil company Shell’s first sustainability report in 1997, according to Wikipedia.
How it shows up in business and investing
The clearest sign of influence is reporting. The Global Reporting Initiative requires firms to report on economic, environmental and social metrics. The HEC factsheet gave its 2017 application rates as 75% of the world’s 250 largest corporations by revenue and 63% of the national top 100 firms.
Investors picked up the same logic. The same factsheet reports that US assets under management using ESG investment strategies were $11.6 trillion at the start of 2018, or one in four dollars. That was up 274% from $3 trillion in 2016.
The Robeco glossary says the concept later morphed into environmental, social and governance factors, or ESG. The HEC factsheet adds that the idea also infused benchmarks such as the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices.

How a business can apply it
Wikipedia offers a simple picture of all three lines working together. In its example, a social enterprise earns income by offering people labelled “unemployable” a living through recycling. The social benefit is meaningful employment and lower welfare costs, and the environmental benefit comes from the recycling.
A practical way to start is to treat each line as a real measure, not a slogan:
- Pick at least one measurable indicator for people, one for planet and one for profit.
- List the stakeholders your decisions affect, and ask what each of them gains or loses.
- Report the three results together, so the financial figure cannot quietly overshadow the others.
On the planet line, power is often the biggest lever, and renewable energy for businesses covers that route. For concrete tools beyond energy, green technology examples shows what is already in use.
Be wary of covering only one line. In a 2008 interview, Elkington said Wal-Mart’s supply-chain work was largely in the environmental and cost-saving space, which he described as taking us back to the years of eco-efficiency. The Mother Jones Q&A shows how even strong green programmes can leave the social line untouched.
Why critics say it falls short
The HEC factsheet lists recurring criticisms of the framework:
- It lacks originality compared with earlier attempts to broaden how firm performance is measured.
- Social and environmental results cannot be measured the way the financial bottom line is, so there is no true net sum.
- It is vague about how to weight the three lines, so the financial one de facto prevails.
Elkington has agreed with part of this. In a 2018 Harvard Business Review article, he admitted the approach had not counteracted corporations’ narrow profit orientation, and he publicly “recalled” the concept, according to the same factsheet. He urged a faster and more radical transformation of how business is done.
Some thinkers add a fourth pillar instead. Wikipedia notes the quadruple bottom line, whose extra pillar is a future-oriented approach covering future generations and intergenerational equity. It also says that despite the measurement challenges, the framework helps organisations take a longer-term view of their decisions.
Frequently asked questions
Who coined the term triple bottom line?
Show answer
John Elkington is credited with coining it in 1994, according to the HEC factsheet. Wikipedia notes that Freer Spreckley described a similar framework in 1981.
What are the three Ps?
Show answer
They are People, Planet and Profit: the social, environmental and economic bottom lines. Companies are meant to report on all of them, not only on net income.
Is the triple bottom line the same as ESG?
Show answer
Not exactly. The Robeco glossary says the triple bottom line later morphed into ESG, which it calls the bedrock of most sustainable investing processes.
Has the triple bottom line worked?
Show answer
Partly. The HEC factsheet says the idea that corporate value is more than financial performance has spread widely, but it has not fulfilled the lofty hopes its founder placed on it.



