Wondering how a company can make money without selling ever more stuff? A circular economy business model keeps products and materials in use, through options like repair, remanufacturing or product-as-a-service. Researchers found 26 major types to choose from.
This explainer sits within the wider topic of sustainability in business, where circular models are one route among several.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Major circular business model types found in one literature review | 26 types |
| Publications used in the morphological analysis | 12 publications |
| Design options for the value proposition | 6 product and 9 service options |
| Possible design combinations (not checked for logic) | 4,445,280 combinations |
| Review published in the Journal of Industrial Ecology | April 2018 |
These figures come from a summary of the review in The Conversation. Research findings can change as new studies appear, so check the source before you rely on them.
What is a circular economy business model?
A circular economy business model is the way a company creates, delivers and earns from value while closing material and energy flows. The aim is to move away from a “cradle to grave” path and towards “cradle to cradle”, as described by the researchers in The Conversation.
In practice, the same source says this can mean:
- replacing non-renewable inputs with renewable ones;
- using recycled materials;
- creating products that are easier to refurbish or remanufacture;
- replacing physical products with less material-intensive services.
The underlying idea is not new. It traces back to industrial ecology, which has promoted eco-industrial parks and other nature-inspired concepts since the early 1990s, according to the same article.
Why there are so many circular business models
A review by Prof. Stefan Gold, Prof. Nancy Bocken and a co-author, published in the Journal of Industrial Ecology in April 2018, found 26 major business model types. These include remanufacturing, waste exchange and product-as-a-service, as The Conversation reports.
The team built a “morphological box” from 12 publications that describe distinguishable circular business model types. It looks for recurring design choices, such as replacing products with services, using recycled materials or offering function-based pricing.
The box splits a business model into parts you can design one at a time:
- the value proposition, meaning the offering made to customers;
- value delivery activities, which bring the offering to customers;
- value creation activities, which engage stakeholders and use resources;
- the value capturing logic, meaning costs, revenues and how the company makes a living.
For the value proposition alone, the researchers found six product and nine service options, such as refurbished products and take-back management services. Combining one option per dimension gives 4,445,280 combinations, and the researchers say that over 4 million designs are theoretically possible.
They also warn against taking that number too seriously. The review is not exhaustive, and the count does not check for illogical combinations, so treat it as a sign of design freedom rather than a forecast.

Examples named in the sources
The sources point to a few concrete cases. Each shows a different design choice rather than a single recipe.
- Product replaced by service: Interface Inc offers floor-covering services rather than carpets, according to The Conversation.
- Refurbished products: Back Market is cited as a source of refurbished smartphones and is described as working on take-back services.
- Mobility as a service: the Technology Innovation Management Review suggests providing mobility as a service instead of selling cars or motorcycles.
The same review points to sharing-economy models such as Uber and Airbnb as examples of disruptive models that are already changing the whole value network. It treats the sharing economy and service business as trends that support the move towards a circular economy.
If you want hardware and technology cases rather than business model designs, these green technology examples are a useful next read. For refurbished phones and similar products, the carbon footprint of digital technology adds the environmental side of the picture.
Why it changes more than production
Generations of engineers, operations managers and business administrators spent decades or even centuries optimising forward supply chains. To become more circular, companies must develop and improve the reverse flows of those supply chains, and sooner or later that means adapting the business model, as The Conversation explains.
The TIM Review article adds that closing material loops often affects many, if not all, aspects of a company’s current model. That covers products or services, relationships with customers and partners, production processes and revenue models.
One shift it highlights is seeing customers as users rather than buyers. Moving from product to service can motivate companies to extend product life through repair and remanufacturing.
The same article is frank about the risk. The transformation can destroy the usefulness of an established company’s existing capabilities, networks and business models. It even asks how an economy that does not create waste can make sense for manufacturers or retailers.
A framework for designing your own model
In the TIM Review’s July 2016 issue, Maria Antikainen and Katri Valkokari argue that most business modelling tools lack some elements needed for circular innovation. Their framework adds three perspectives:
- recognising trends and drivers at the ecosystem level;
- understanding value to partners and stakeholders within a business;
- evaluating the impact of sustainability and circularity.
They tested the framework with a Finnish startup. They also note that business model innovation is often piecemeal or incremental rather than system-wide, and that, as of that 2016 article, the European Union had launched a Circular Economy Package to encourage greater recycling and re-use. The full text is on the TIM Review site.
The Conversation authors list questions a company has to answer for itself:
- Do we have to change our forward and reverse supply chains?
- Should we do it now, or only when regulators and customers ask us to?
- Can we improve our competitive position by moving towards closed-loop supply chains?
Their own research cannot answer these in general, because the answers are highly case-dependent. Use the design options as a menu, not as a prescription.
What the evidence does not tell you
Both sources are older research pieces: the TIM Review article dates from July 2016 and The Conversation piece was published in May 2019. Neither claims that a given model will be profitable for your business.
The strongest takeaway is practical. A circular model is a combination of choices across offering, delivery, creation and revenue, so you can test one dimension at a time before committing to a full redesign.
Frequently asked questions
What is a circular economy business model?
Show answer
It is a way of creating, delivering and capturing value that closes material and energy flows, for example through recycled inputs, refurbishment, remanufacturing or services that replace physical products.
How many types of circular business model are there?
Show answer
A review published in April 2018 found 26 major types. Their design options allow for more than 4 million combinations in theory, though the authors say not to take that number too seriously.
What is an example of a circular business model?
Show answer
Interface Inc offers floor-covering services rather than carpets, according to The Conversation. Back Market, a source of refurbished smartphones, is another example named in the same article.
Why is it hard for established companies?
Show answer
Their supply chains were optimised for forward flows, and closing loops can affect products, customer relationships, production and revenue models. The TIM Review notes it can even destroy the usefulness of existing capabilities.



