Open Innovation: Collaborating Beyond Your Company

open innovation

Wondering whether your team can really innovate alone? Open innovation means using outside ideas, partners and routes to market alongside your own. Done well, it cuts cost and speeds learning; done badly, it leaks what you know.

Open innovation is one lens within business strategy, and it shapes where your next ideas, partners and customers come from.

Item Value
Year the term “open innovation” was coined 2003
Chesbrough’s book on the topic Published in 2003 by Harvard Business School Press
Approaches by direction of flow 2 (inbound and outbound)
Models by knowledge flow 3 (outside-in, inside-out, coupled)

These figures come from Temera’s explainer and HYPE Innovation’s guide to the models. Definitions and counts can change as the field develops, so check the sources before you rely on them.

What is open innovation?

The term was coined in 2003 by the economist Henry Chesbrough, according to Temera. His definition is a paradigm that assumes firms can and should use external ideas as well as internal ideas, and internal and external paths to market. His book on the subject was published in 2003 by Harvard Business School Press.

The idea has older roots. Wikipedia notes that the benefits of openness were discussed as far back as the 1960s, especially for cooperation between firms in R&D. It runs counter to the secrecy and silo mentality of traditional corporate research labs.

A more recent definition, also cited on Wikipedia, describes a distributed innovation process built on purposively managed knowledge flows across organizational boundaries. That wording acknowledges that open innovation is not solely firm-centric, so customers and user communities count too.

Chesbrough himself puts the core belief simply, as quoted by HYPE Innovation: the sources of knowledge for innovation are widely distributed in the economy. Your best idea may already sit with a supplier, a university lab or a startup.

Inbound and outbound open innovation

Temera divides open innovation into two types of approach, depending on which way ideas travel.

  • Inbound: you buy or license processes or inventions, such as patents, from other companies. Contests and competitions can also gather ideas on a specific problem.
  • Outbound: you take internal inventions you are not using in your own business outside the company, for example through licensing, joint ventures or spin-offs.

The same Temera article says outbound activity is less used because it is considered less safe for protecting a company’s intellectual property. It also reports that less widespread inbound activities, such as internal incubators, accelerators and corporate venture capital, have often led to greater results.

open innovation Connecting pieces
Two hands hold small white puzzle pieces facing each other against a light background.

Three models based on knowledge flow

The HYPE Innovation guide says open innovation theory refers to three different models, depending on the direction of the knowledge flow you want to use.

  1. Outside-in (inbound knowledge flow): you pull in ideas, technology and signals from outside.
  2. Inside-out (outbound knowledge flow): you push your own strengths and assets outward.
  3. Coupled: you combine knowledge inflows and outflows.

Outside-in in practice

Outside-in companies start by asking where the growth markets are and how to serve market needs better. HYPE Innovation lists several routes:

  • Corporate and startup collaboration: startups can benefit from corporate funding, resources and customer access, while corporations get ahead of disruption and reach new technology.
  • Supplier-sourced innovation: suppliers can help solve problems that no single organization can solve on its own.
  • In-licensing IP: you license in another company’s solution. The source’s example is director Peter Jackson, who needed a license from the Saul Zaentz Company to make “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy.
  • University cooperation: this can take the form of research, consultancy, science park developments, or co-developing curricula and apprenticeships.

Inside-out in practice

The inside-out approach is guided by the belief that an organization’s inner strengths and capabilities will generate its sustainable future, says HYPE Innovation. It starts with your core competencies, talent, resources and customer relationships, then asks how they can be leveraged.

Benefits and risks of open innovation

The upside is mostly about cost and speed. Wikipedia lists reduced cost of conducting research and development, potential for better development productivity, and incorporating customers early in development. Temera adds great speed of innovation from using existing resources, since you can turn to technologies already developed.

The downside is mostly about control. Watch for these risks:

  • Revealing information that was not meant to be shared, or losing competitive advantage by exposing intellectual property (Wikipedia).
  • More complexity in controlling innovation and in regulating how contributors affect a project (Wikipedia).
  • Higher costs for partner agreements and more management time to coordinate internal and external resources (Temera).
  • Less ability to patent an innovation once it has been disclosed (Temera).

Startups, universities and government programmes

Smaller firms can gain the most. Wikipedia says open innovation has allowed startups to produce innovation comparable to that of large companies, because they can overcome limited resources and experience by leveraging external resources and knowledge. If you are a founder testing ideas against real customers, the lean startup methodology covers that side in more depth.

Governments sometimes fund the link. In the UK, knowledge transfer partnerships are a funding mechanism that encourages partnership between a firm and a knowledge-based partner, according to Wikipedia. Each one involves three parties: a knowledge-based partner such as a research institution, a company partner, and one or more associates, who are recently qualified people such as graduates.

How do you start without giving away too much?

Begin small and decide the rules early. Temera says the approach involves a careful review of business processes and a careful selection of people who are open-minded and accepting of change. Use that as your first check.

  1. Pick a direction. Decide whether you need to bring ideas in, push assets out, or both.
  2. Pick a partner type. Suppliers, startups, universities and contest participants each solve different problems.
  3. Draw the IP line. Decide what you will share, license or keep private before talks begin.
  4. Budget coordination time. Partner agreements and management effort carry real cost.
  5. Review what you learned. Keep partnerships that open new demand and end those that only leak knowledge.

If your goal is to find demand nobody is serving yet, pairing outside input with blue ocean strategy thinking is one way to frame the search.

Frequently asked questions

What is open innovation in simple terms?

Show answer

It is a way of innovating in which a company uses outside ideas, technologies and partners as well as its own, and lets unused internal ideas travel outward. Chesbrough’s definition says firms can and should use external ideas as well as internal ones.

What is the difference between inbound and outbound open innovation?

Show answer

Inbound brings external inventions or ideas into your company, for example by licensing patents or running contests. Outbound sends your unused internal inventions out through licensing, joint ventures or spin-offs.

Can small companies use open innovation?

Show answer

Yes. Wikipedia says startups can work with large companies, incubators, VC firms and higher education to get the resources and support they lack.

What are the main risks?

Show answer

The biggest are leaking information, losing competitive advantage and added management complexity. Partner agreements also add cost, so set your sharing rules before you start.