Blue Ocean Strategy: Ideas and Limits

blue ocean strategy

Wondering whether blue ocean strategy is worth your time? It is a framework for escaping crowded markets by creating new demand, built on value innovation. It offers useful tools, but it is qualitative, so test it against your own market.

This guide sits inside our wider business strategy coverage.

Item Value
Authors W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne, professors at INSEAD
Book first published 2005
Expanded edition 2015
Sequels Blue Ocean Shift (2017) and Beyond Disruption (2023)
Study behind the book 150 strategic moves, more than 100 years, 30 industries
Core idea Value innovation: differentiation and low cost pursued together

The figures come from Wikipedia’s page on the book and the Agile Brand Guide. Details such as dates and study scope can change or be corrected, so check the sources before you rely on them.

What blue ocean strategy actually claims

The idea comes from W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne, whose book was published in 2005, according to Wikipedia. They assert that their strategic moves create a leap in value for the company, its buyers and its employees, while unlocking new demand and making the competition irrelevant. The key term is uncontested market space: a “blue ocean” is a market area nobody is fighting over yet.

The contrast is the “red ocean”, the conventional approach that focuses on beating competitors and is derived from military organization. The authors challenge the usual choice between differentiation and lower cost, and suggest you can have both at once. The Agile Brand Guide calls this value innovation the cornerstone of the framework.

Where it came from

Wikipedia says the concept was developed in the 1990s, when Kim took part in a consulting project for Philips headed by the management scholar C. K. Prahalad. The Agile Brand Guide says it was introduced in a 2004 Harvard Business Review article. It also says the book rests on a study of 150 strategic moves spanning more than 100 years and 30 industries.

The book later grew into a small family of titles:

  • An expanded edition in 2015.
  • Blue Ocean Shift in 2017.
  • Beyond Disruption in 2023.

The core tools: strategy canvas, four actions and ERRC

The strategy canvas plots the factors an industry competes on against the level of offering buyers receive on each. The resulting line is the value curve. According to the Agile Brand Guide, a blue ocean strategy shows up as a curve that diverges meaningfully from competitors, with different factors and different levels.

The four actions framework then asks what to change. Wikipedia lists the same four actions in its description of the book.

Action Question it asks
Eliminate Which factors the industry takes for granted should go?
Reduce Which factors should fall well below the industry standard?
Raise Which factors should rise well above the industry standard?
Create Which factors has the industry never offered?

The questions above are paraphrased from the Agile Brand Guide, and Wikipedia lists the same actions; wording can change, so check the sources before you rely on it.

Eliminate and Reduce lower the cost structure, while Raise and Create lift buyer value and generate new demand. The ERRC grid is the worksheet that records each answer. It exists to make sure all four actions are addressed, not just raise and create, which the source calls the common failure mode.

blue ocean strategy Calm waters
A sailboat rests on pale, calm water beneath a softly clouded sky.

If you want a companion exercise, a swot analysis example can help you describe your own position before you redraw the value curve.

How do you find new market space?

Wikipedia describes the formulation side of the book as four principles. They push you to look at the big picture rather than the detail, and to get the strategic sequence right. The first moves are about widening your view:

  • Look across the six conventional boundaries of competition, known as the Six Paths Framework.
  • Reduce planning risk by following the four steps of visualizing strategy.
  • Create new demand by unlocking the three tiers of non-customers.
  • Align the offering’s utility with strategic pricing and target costing, and plan for adoption hurdles.

The non-customer idea is the most practical for small teams. Instead of asking how to win share from rivals, you ask why people who buy nothing in your category stay out. That question tends to surface factors your industry has never questioned. For a different way of pulling outside ideas into a company, see our piece on open innovation.

Getting it done inside the organisation

The book’s third part covers two implementation principles: tipping point leadership and fair process. They are meant to overcome four hurdles that can stop even a good strategy from being executed:

  1. Cognitive: people do not see the need to break from the status quo.
  2. Resource: the means to carry out the shift are hard to find.
  3. Motivational: people lose commitment to the new strategy.
  4. Political: powerful vested interests block the change.

Two examples that are often cited

The Agile Brand Guide names Cirque du Soleil as a frequently cited example. Rather than compete with traditional circuses for a shrinking market, it combined elements of theatre and circus. The guide says it reached in 20 years revenue that Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey took over a century to attain.

The Nintendo Wii video game console, first released in 2006, has often been considered an example of the blue ocean concept, according to Wikipedia. The same page says Nintendo did not try to compete with the high performance and computational power of the consoles from Sony and Microsoft. Both cases show the pattern: change the factors you compete on rather than outdoing rivals on the old ones.

Where the idea has limits

Treat the framework as a thinking aid, not a forecast. The Agile Brand Guide says plainly that it is a qualitative framework rather than a numerical calculation, so it cannot tell you whether a new market is big enough. The “leap in value” is also what the authors assert, not an independently measured result.

The source base is another caution. As of a May 2020 maintenance notice, Wikipedia’s article said it reads like a press release and may rest largely on routine coverage, and asked for independent secondary sources. Cases like Cirque du Soleil are also described after the fact, which makes them easier to fit to the model than a live decision is.

Before committing, run a few practical checks:

  • Fill in all four boxes of the ERRC grid, including the uncomfortable Eliminate and Reduce boxes.
  • Name the non-customers you expect to win and test why they stay out today.
  • List which of the four hurdles is most likely to stall you, and who owns it.
  • Seek evidence beyond the authors’ own books before you commit large budgets.

Frequently asked questions

What is blue ocean strategy in one sentence?

Show answer

It is a framework that argues for creating new, uncontested market space through value innovation instead of fighting rivals in an existing market.

Who created it?

Show answer

W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne, professors at INSEAD. Their book appeared in 2005, following a 2004 Harvard Business Review article, according to the sources above.

What is the difference between red and blue oceans?

Show answer

Red oceans are existing industries where rivals compete head-to-head for share. Blue oceans are spaces where demand is created rather than fought over.

Is blue ocean strategy proven to work?

Show answer

The authors assert it does, and they cite a study of 150 strategic moves. The framework itself is qualitative, so you should test any blue ocean idea on a small scale before you rely on it.