Making Better Decisions with Data

data-driven decision making

Worried your team runs on gut feel? Data-driven decision making means using evidence, not instinct alone, to choose. Start with a clear question, trustworthy data, and a way to check the result.

This guide sits within the business technology section of the site.

Item Value
Companies basing at least half of regular decisions on gut feel or experience 58% of respondents
Gut feel dominates decisions: best-in-class vs. laggard companies 40% vs. 70%
Share of available information used for decisions 50% on average
Standard KPIs defined vs. used pervasively 79% vs. 36%
Companies that reached a single data source 6%
Median number of internal data sources 5

These figures come from the BARC global survey on data-driven decision-making, last edited in August 2016. Figures like these can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

Data-driven decision making in plain terms

Datamation’s January 2024 guide describes data-driven decision-making as an approach that emphasizes using data and analysis instead of intuition to inform business decisions. It draws on sources such as customer feedback, market trends and financial data (Datamation).

That does not mean experience has no role. It means experience becomes an input you can test against evidence, rather than the whole argument. BARC’s survey found that businesses with a collaborative style of decision-making treat information much more as an asset than companies with other approaches (BARC).

Governance sits underneath all of this. A paper on operations and supply chains defines data governance as “the exercise of authority and control over the management of data asset” (arXiv). In practice, someone is named as responsible for each dataset your decisions rely on.

Why gut feel still wins so often

BARC’s survey found that 58% of respondents say their companies base at least half of their regular business decisions on gut feel or experience. The survey was last edited in August 2016, so treat it as a snapshot of that time rather than a picture of today (BARC).

The gap between strong and weak performers is telling. Best-in-class companies base the majority of their decisions on gut feel or experience less often than laggards do, at 40% versus 70%. A survey shows an association, not proof of cause, but BARC reads it as a link between using information and gaining a strategic advantage (BARC).

data-driven decision making Chart review
A man wearing glasses holds a pencil near his face beside a board displaying charts.

Even organizations that use data leave much of it idle. On average, organizations only use 50% of all available information for decision-making, according to the same BARC survey.

A six-step process for better decisions

Datamation lists six steps that fit most decisions, from a pricing change to a hiring plan (Datamation). Use them as a checklist:

  1. Define objectives. State the decision and the goal it serves.
  2. Identify and collect data. Gather data aligned with those objectives.
  3. Organize and explore. Structure the data so you can see what it contains.
  4. Analyze. Look for patterns, trends and correlations.
  5. Draw conclusions. Build a narrative so your team shares the same understanding.
  6. Implement and evaluate. Act on the plan, then monitor its effect on your objectives.

Datamation cites Walmart using historical data and predictive analytics to place holiday items across stores, and Purdue University using a tool called Course Signals to predict which students are at risk of not completing a course (Datamation). These are illustrations, not endorsements, and they do not prove the same approach will work for you.

A practical habit: write down the decision and its success measure before you open any spreadsheet. Step six then has something concrete to check against.

What gets in the way of using data?

BARC found that the most commonly cited reason for not using information is that the necessary information was not available. Data quality is the second biggest barrier (BARC).

A paper built upon three case studies in operations and supply chains found four types of cause behind data issues (arXiv):

  • Human factors
  • Lack of written rules and regulations
  • Ineffective technological hardware and software
  • Lack of resources

The same authors argue that unless problems such as missing data, duplication and erratic labeling are solved, it is meaningless to adopt business intelligence systems or data science technologies (arXiv). Better tools do not rescue bad inputs.

Scattered data and unclear ownership also slow things down. A qualitative case study of a global pharmaceutical IT programme, published in 2025, found severe fragmentation of data sources and ambiguity of ownership, with delayed decisions, duplicated tasks and a weaker audit trail (European Research Studies Journal). It is a single case, so read it as an example, not a rule.

Multiple sources are normal. BARC reports a median of 5 internal data sources, and only 6% of respondents had reached the goal of a single source (BARC).

How to build the habit across a team

Shared measures come first. In BARC’s survey, 79% of respondents have a defined, standard set of KPIs, but only 36% use them pervasively across the organization (BARC). Agree on a short list of KPIs and use them in every review.

BARC’s call for action lists what organizations need to do to unlock the data they leave unused:

  • Address and improve data quality
  • Lower the cost of access to information
  • Improve the way in which information is presented
  • Make information easier to find
  • Increase the speed at which information is made available
  • Raise awareness of business intelligence at senior management levels
  • Foster a collaborative style of decision-making

Tool choice matters less than trusted data, so weigh options such as the low-code no-code platforms against the quality of what feeds them.

The arXiv authors note that “big” data stimulates companies to move towards data-driven decision making, yet also becomes an obstacle on that journey (arXiv). That is why data habits belong inside a wider digital transformation strategy, not in a side project.

Frequently asked questions

What is data-driven decision making?

Show answer

Datamation defines it as an approach that emphasizes using data and analysis instead of intuition to inform business decisions. It follows a loop of defining objectives, collecting and analyzing data, drawing conclusions and evaluating the result (Datamation, January 2024).

Does it mean ignoring experience?

Show answer

Not in a practical sense. A sensible approach is to treat experience as a hypothesis and check it against data, then record what you learn so the next decision starts from better evidence.

What should you fix first?

Show answer

Start with availability and quality. BARC’s respondents named missing information as the most common barrier and data quality as the second (BARC, last edited August 2016).

Are the survey figures still accurate?

Show answer

They are a historical benchmark. The BARC survey was last edited in August 2016, so measure your own share of gut-feel decisions and data use before comparing yourself with it.